Pinky Promise: The Babysitter's Last Night Part 2
Pinky Promise: The Babysitter's Last Night Part 2
CHAPTER 9: The Letter
A month passed.
Thanksgiving came and went. Ethan's mom made a turkey, even though it was just the three of them. She burned the rolls and forgot to buy gravy, but nobody cared. They ate in front of the TV, watching the parade, and for a few hours, things felt almost normal.
Lily's nightmares got better. She still woke up sometimes, crying and reaching for Mr. Hops, but she went back to sleep faster now. She stopped asking Ethan to sleep on her floor. She stopped checking the locks before bed.
Ethan went back to school after Thanksgiving break. His friends asked where he'd been. He said he'd had the flu. They believed him. Why wouldn't they?
He didn't tell them about Sarah. He didn't tell them about the doorbell or the key or the garage. That was his secret. His and his mom's and Lily's.
Some secrets, he was learning, were worth keeping.
On the first day of December, a letter arrived.
It was in a plain white envelope, addressed to "Ethan Keller" in handwriting he didn't recognize. There was no return address. The postmark said "Franklin County Jail."
Ethan's heart stopped.
He knew who it was from.
He took the letter to his room and closed the door. He sat on his bed and stared at the envelope for a long time. The paper was thin and cheap. The handwriting was messy — loops and curves that slanted to the right, like the person who wrote it had been in a hurry.
He opened it.
Dear Ethan,
You don't know me. Not really. You know the version of me that showed up at your door — the desperate, broken woman who tried to take your sister. But that's not who I am. That's not who I was.
I'm writing to say I'm sorry.
I'm sorry for scaring you. I'm sorry for scaring Lily. I'm sorry for putting you in a position where you had to protect your sister from someone who was supposed to be family.
I'm not sorry for wanting Lily. She's my daughter. She came out of my body. I held her first. I named her first. And then they took her away.
Your mom didn't steal her, not legally. The court decided I was unfit. Maybe I was. Maybe I am. But I've been clean for three years now. I have a job. I have an apartment. I have a life.
But I don't have Lily.
I thought if I could just see her — just hold her — everything would be okay. I thought if I could explain, you would understand. You're a kid. Kids understand things that adults don't.
I was wrong.
I'm sorry.
I'm in a hospital now. Not the jail — a hospital. They're trying to help me. They're trying to fix whatever is broken in my brain. I don't know if it will work. I don't know if anything will work.
But I want you to know that I never wanted to hurt you. I never wanted to hurt Lily. I just wanted to love her.
I'm sorry.
Sarah
Ethan read the letter three times.
Then he folded it up and put it back in the envelope.
He didn't know what to feel. Angry? Sad? Confused? All of the above?
She had written "I'm sorry" three times. But she had also written "I'm not sorry for wanting Lily." She had written "She's my daughter." She had written "They took her away."
She didn't understand.
She would never understand.
Lily wasn't hers. Lily had never been hers. Lily was Ethan's sister. Lily was his mom's daughter. Lily was part of their family — the family that ate burnt turkey on Thanksgiving and watched parades on TV and forgot to buy gravy.
Sarah was a stranger.
A stranger who shared DNA with Lily, maybe. But DNA didn't make a family.
Love made a family.
And Sarah's love — if that's what it was — had almost destroyed them.
Ethan put the envelope in his desk drawer. He didn't know if he would show it to his mom. He didn't know if he would show it to Dr. Chen. He didn't know if he would keep it forever or throw it away tomorrow.
But for now, he kept it.
A reminder.
Of what he had survived.
Of what he had lost.
Of what he had gained.
That night, after dinner, Ethan went into Lily's room. She was sitting on her bed, brushing Mr. Hops's fur with a tiny pink brush.
"Lily?" he said.
She looked up. "Yeah?"
"Do you know what adoption means?"
Lily tilted her head. "Like... when you get a dog from the pound?"
"Sort of. It's when a kid doesn't have parents who can take care of them, so another family takes them in and loves them like their own."
Lily thought about this. "Like we adopted Mr. Hops?"
Ethan smiled. "Something like that."
"Why?"
"Because I want you to know that families are made of love. Not blood. Not DNA. Love. And I love you, Lily. You're my sister. That's never going to change."
Lily put down the brush. She crawled to the edge of the bed and held out her pinky.
"Pinky promise?" she said.
Ethan hooked his pinky around hers.
"Pinky promise," he said.
And for the first time in a long time, he meant it with his whole heart.
CHAPTER 10: The New Normal
Spring came slowly to Ohio.
The snow melted. The trees budded. The grass turned from brown to green. The Keller house, which had felt dark and cold for so many months, started to feel like home again.
Ethan's mom moved the couch back to its original spot in March. She asked him first — "Is it okay if I move it? Or do you want to keep it where it is?"
Ethan looked at the couch. It had been pushed against the front door for four months. It had saved their lives. But it was also a reminder — a constant, physical reminder of the worst night of his life.
"Move it," he said.
His mom moved it. The living room looked different without it blocking the door. Bigger. Brighter. Less like a fortress.
Ethan started sleeping through the night in April. He didn't know why. He just fell asleep one night and woke up the next morning and realized he hadn't thought about Sarah at all. Not once.
It felt like a miracle.
Lily turned five in May. They had a party in the backyard — a small one, just family and a few neighbors. There was a cake shaped like a unicorn and balloons tied to the fence and a piñata that looked like a rainbow. Lily wore a crown made of paper flowers and ate so much candy she threw up on the grass.
Ethan's mom cried during the birthday song. Happy tears. The first happy tears Ethan had seen her cry in a long time.
In June, Sarah's trial began.
Ethan didn't have to testify. The prosecutor said his statement to Officer Martinez was enough. The case was clear — attempted kidnapping, breaking and entering, assault. Sarah's lawyer tried to argue that she was mentally incompetent, but the judge didn't buy it.
Sarah was sentenced to ten years in prison.
Ethan watched the news report on TV. They showed a picture of her — a mugshot, her face pale and tired, her eyes empty. She looked nothing like the woman who had smiled at him through the peephole.
"Are you okay?" his mom asked, sitting down next to him.
"I don't know," he said. "I think so."
"You don't have to be okay."
"I know."
They watched the rest of the report in silence. The reporter talked about "community response" and "vigilance" and "protecting our children." Words that didn't mean anything. Words that couldn't capture what Ethan had been through.
He turned off the TV.
"Mom?" he said.
"Yeah?"
"Can we go to the zoo this weekend? Lily's been asking."
His mom smiled. It was a real smile — not the tired, worried smile she'd been wearing for months. A real one.
"Yeah," she said. "I think we can do that."
On Saturday, they went to the zoo.
Lily wore her bunny pajamas under her clothes — a new habit she'd picked up after the incident. She said Mr. Hops liked being close to her heart. Ethan didn't argue. If wearing pajamas to the zoo made her feel safe, then she could wear pajamas to the zoo.
They saw the elephants and the giraffes and the penguins. Lily fed a goat in the petting zoo and screamed when it tried to eat her hair. Ethan bought a snow cone — blue raspberry, his favorite — and got brain freeze.
For a few hours, they were just a normal family doing normal things.
And then, at the end of the day, they sat on a bench overlooking the lion enclosure. The sun was setting, painting the sky in shades of orange and pink. Lily was asleep in the stroller, Mr. Hops tucked under her arm.
"Ethan," his mom said.
"Yeah?"
"I never thanked you."
"For what?"
"For saving Lily's life. For saving our family. For being braver than any twelve-year-old should have to be."
Ethan looked at the lions. They were lying in the grass, their golden fur glowing in the setting sun. They looked peaceful. Safe.
"I was just doing what anyone would do," he said.
"No," his mom said. "You were doing what you did. And I will spend the rest of my life being grateful."
Ethan didn't know what to say. So he didn't say anything.
He just sat there, on the bench, watching the sunset, with his mom on one side and his sister on the other.
And for the first time since the doorbell rang, he felt safe.
Not completely safe. Not perfectly safe. But safe enough.
And maybe — just maybe — that was enough.
CHAPTER 11: The Anniversary
One year.
Three hundred sixty-five days since the doorbell rang.
Ethan stood in his living room, staring at the front door. The door that had been pushed open by police officers. The door that had been repaired and repainted. The door that still had a small scratch on the frame from when the couch had been shoved against it.
He touched the scratch. It was rough under his fingertips.
"Ethan? Are you ready?"
His mom's voice came from the kitchen. She was making hot chocolate — the kind with whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles that Lily loved. It was a cold November evening, the kind that made you want to stay inside and watch movies and pretend the world didn't exist.
"Yeah," Ethan said. "I'm ready."
He walked into the kitchen. Lily was sitting at the table, kicking her feet, waiting for her hot chocolate. She was five now — almost six — and she'd lost two more teeth since the incident. She looked older. Different. But still Lily.
"Today is the day," Lily said. She didn't say it like it was a bad thing. Just a fact.
"Yeah," Ethan said. "Today is the day."
"What are we going to do?"
Ethan looked at his mom. They'd talked about this — planned it, even. They didn't want to pretend the anniversary didn't exist. But they didn't want to dwell on it either.
"We're going to have hot chocolate," his mom said, placing three mugs on the table. "And then we're going to watch a movie. And then we're going to order pizza for dinner."
"Can we get pepperoni?" Lily asked.
"We can get whatever you want."
Lily grinned, showing off the gap where her front tooth used to be.
Ethan sat down and wrapped his hands around his mug. The ceramic was warm. The chocolate smelled sweet. The whipped cream was already starting to melt.
"Toast," his mom said, raising her mug.
"Toast," Ethan echoed.
"Toast!" Lily said, raising her mug so high that some of the hot chocolate sloshed over the side.
They clinked their mugs together.
"To being together," his mom said.
"To being together," Ethan and Lily said.
They drank their hot chocolate. Lily got whipped cream on her nose. Ethan laughed — a real laugh, the kind that came from somewhere deep in his chest. His mom laughed too, and for a moment, the house felt warm and safe and full of love.
After the movie — Toy Story 4, Lily's current obsession — Ethan went up to his room. He opened his desk drawer and pulled out the envelope.
Sarah's letter.
He hadn't looked at it in months. He'd thought about throwing it away a hundred times. But something always stopped him.
Today, he read it again.
Dear Ethan,
You don't know me...
He read the whole thing. Every word. Every apology. Every excuse.
Then he folded it up, put it back in the envelope, and walked downstairs.
His mom was in the kitchen, washing the mugs. Lily was in the living room, building a fort out of pillows and blankets.
"Mom?" Ethan said.
"Yeah?"
"I want to show you something."
He handed her the envelope.
His mom dried her hands on a dish towel and opened it. She read the letter in silence, her face unreadable. When she finished, she looked up at Ethan.
"Where did you get this?"
"It came in the mail. In December. I didn't know what to do with it."
"How long have you been carrying this?"
"Almost a year."
His mom closed her eyes. When she opened them, they were wet.
"You should have told me," she said. "You shouldn't have had to carry this alone."
"I didn't want to hurt you."
"Ethan..." She knelt down so she was at eye level with him. "You don't have to protect me. I'm the parent. I'm supposed to protect you."
"But you were hurting too."
"I was. I am. But that doesn't mean I can't handle your pain. That's what family is for. We carry each other."
Ethan felt something crack inside his chest. Something he'd been holding together for a very long time.
"I don't know what to do with it," he said, pointing at the letter. "Throw it away? Keep it? Send her a response?"
His mom thought about it.
"There's no right answer," she said. "There's only what feels right to you."
"What feels right to me?"
"Yes. What does your gut say?"
Ethan looked at the letter. Sarah's messy handwriting. Her desperate words. Her broken apologies.
"I don't want to keep it," he said. "It makes me feel heavy."
"Then don't keep it."
"But I don't want to throw it away either. What if I need it someday? What if I forget?"
His mom took his hand. "You won't forget. You can't forget. But you can let go of the things that weigh you down. That's not the same as forgetting."
Ethan looked at the letter one more time.
Then he walked to the recycling bin and dropped it in.
His mom didn't say anything. She just put her arm around his shoulders and pulled him close.
"I'm proud of you," she said.
Ethan leaned into her. He was taller than her now — just a little — but he still fit perfectly under her arm.
"I'm proud of us," he said.
And he meant it.
CHAPTER 12: The Court Date
Fifteen months after the incident, Ethan's mom received a letter.
It was from the Franklin County District Attorney's Office. Sarah had filed an appeal. She wanted a new trial. She wanted to argue that she hadn't received adequate legal representation the first time around.
Ethan's mom read the letter three times. Then she called her lawyer.
"Can she do that?" she asked, her voice shaking.
"She can try," the lawyer said. "But it's unlikely to succeed. Her case was solid. The evidence was overwhelming. The judge's ruling was fair."
"But she can still try?"
"She can. And you may have to testify."
Ethan's mom hung up the phone and sat at the kitchen table for a long time. Her hands were trembling. Her face was pale.
"Mom?" Ethan said, coming into the kitchen. "What's wrong?"
His mom told him.
Ethan sat down across from her. He didn't say anything at first. He just let the information sink in.
"If you have to testify," he said finally, "I want to come with you."
"Ethan, you don't have to —"
"I know I don't have to. I want to."
His mom looked at him. He was thirteen now. He'd had a birthday in October — a quiet one, with cake and presents and a phone call from Grandma Marie in Florida. He was taller. His voice was deeper. He looked more like a young man and less like a little boy.
"Are you sure?" she asked.
"I'm sure."
The court date was set for February.
Ethan didn't tell Lily. Lily was six now, in first grade, and she had stopped having nightmares about the woman in the beige coat. She didn't need to know. She didn't need to carry that weight.
On the morning of the court date, Ethan put on his nicest clothes — a button-down shirt and dark jeans and shoes that weren't sneakers. His mom wore a black dress and her hair in a bun. She looked like a different person. Stronger. More determined.
The courthouse was an old building downtown, with marble floors and high ceilings and security guards who made you empty your pockets. Ethan walked through the metal detector without setting it off. His mom did the same.
They sat in the hallway outside the courtroom. The benches were hard and cold. A few other people were waiting — lawyers in suits, witnesses in nice clothes, a woman with a crying baby who kept apologizing.
"Ethan Keller?"
A young woman in a gray suit stood in front of him. She had a badge clipped to her belt and a folder under her arm.
"I'm Jessica Park, the victim advocate," she said. "I'm here to support you and your mom through the process. Do you have any questions?"
Ethan shook his head.
"Do you know what to expect?"
"I watched a video about it," Ethan said. "On YouTube."
Jessica smiled. "That's smart. Most adults don't do that."
"When will I have to talk?"
"You probably won't have to talk at all. Your statement from last year is enough. But if the judge asks you questions, just tell the truth. That's all anyone expects."
Ethan nodded.
The courtroom doors opened. A bailiff in a dark uniform stepped out.
"All rise for the Honorable Judge Patricia Owens."
Everyone stood. The judge walked in — a woman with short gray hair and glasses and a black robe that made her look like a character from a TV show. She sat down at the bench and adjusted her microphone.
"Be seated."
Ethan sat. His mom sat next to him. Sarah was already in the courtroom, sitting at a table with her lawyer. She looked different — thinner, older, her hair streaked with gray. She wasn't wearing a beige coat. She was wearing an orange jumpsuit.
She didn't look at Ethan.
She didn't look at his mom.
She stared straight ahead, at the judge, her face expressionless.
The hearing lasted two hours.
Lawyers talked. Papers were passed around. Arguments were made. Ethan's mom testified — her voice steady, her answers clear. She talked about the night Sarah had come to their house. She talked about the years before, the letters and the phone calls and the threats she'd ignored.
"No further questions," Sarah's lawyer said.
Ethan's mom stepped down from the witness stand. She walked past Sarah without looking at her.
The judge took a fifteen-minute recess.
When she came back, she had a decision.
"Motion denied," Judge Owens said. "The defendant's appeal is rejected. The original sentence stands."
Ethan let out a breath.
His mom grabbed his hand and squeezed.
Sarah didn't react. She just sat there, staring at the table, her shoulders slumped.
After the hearing, Ethan and his mom walked out of the courthouse into the cold February air. Snow was falling — big, fluffy flakes that melted on contact.
"It's over," his mom said.
"Is it?" Ethan asked.
His mom looked at him. "For now."
They walked to the car in silence. The snow was starting to stick to the sidewalk. Ethan's shoes left footprints behind him.
"Mom?" he said.
"Yeah?"
"Do you think she'll try again? When she gets out?"
His mom stopped walking. She turned to face him, her breath fogging in the cold air.
"I don't know," she said. "I hope not. But I don't know."
"How do we protect Lily if she does?"
"We do what we did last time. We lock the doors. We stay vigilant. And we trust each other."
Ethan thought about that. Trust. It was such a small word for something so important.
"I trust you," he said.
"I trust you too," his mom said.
They got in the car and drove home.
Lily was waiting for them on the front porch, wearing her bunny pajamas and holding Mr. Hops. She waved when she saw the car.
"Mommy! Ethan!" she shouted. "Mrs. Patterson let me have cookies!"
Ethan smiled.
Some things, he realized, were worth protecting.
No matter what.
CHAPTER 13: The Dream
Ethan dreamed about Sarah.
It happened on a random Tuesday in March, six weeks after the court date. There was no trigger — no anniversary, no letter, no mention of her name. He just went to sleep and found himself standing in his living room, staring at the front door.
The doorbell rang.
DING DONG.
Ethan didn't move.
The doorbell rang again.
DING DONG.
He walked to the door. His feet were heavy, like they were made of lead. His arms hung at his sides. He couldn't lift them.
He looked through the peephole.
Sarah was standing on the porch.
But she wasn't the Sarah from the night of the incident. She was younger. Prettier. Her hair was shiny. Her coat was new. Her smile was warm.
"Hi, Ethan," she said. "I'm your aunt Sarah. Can I come in?"
Ethan wanted to say no. He wanted to turn around and run to the garage. He wanted to pull the cord and slam the door.
But he couldn't move.
His hands were frozen. His feet were frozen. His mouth was frozen.
"Ethan?" Sarah called. "Can you hear me? Open the door."
He woke up gasping.
His room was dark. His sheets were tangled around his legs. His heart was pounding so hard he could feel it in his temples.
He sat up and put his head in his hands.
It was just a dream. It was just a dream. It was just a dream.
But his hands were shaking.
He got out of bed and walked to Lily's room. She was asleep, Mr. Hops tucked under her arm, her mouth open, her breathing steady.
He stood in her doorway for a long time, watching her chest rise and fall.
Then he went back to his room and sat on his bed until the sun came up.
The next day, he told Dr. Chen about the dream.
"Nightmares are normal," she said. "Especially after trauma. Your brain is processing what happened, trying to make sense of it."
"It felt so real," Ethan said. "I could hear her voice. I could see her face."
"What did you feel during the dream?"
"Trapped. Frozen. Like I couldn't move no matter how hard I tried."
"That's a common nightmare theme — feeling powerless. In real life, you weren't powerless. You took action. You protected Lily. But your brain still has to work through the fear you felt in the moment."
"How do I make it stop?"
"You may not be able to make it stop completely. But you can learn to cope with it. You can learn to wake yourself up when the dream starts. You can learn to remind yourself that you're safe now."
"How?"
Dr. Chen taught him a technique. It was called "rehearsal." Every night before bed, Ethan was supposed to imagine the dream — but with a different ending. Instead of freezing, he was supposed to imagine himself opening the door and telling Sarah to leave. Instead of feeling trapped, he was supposed to imagine himself feeling strong.
"It sounds fake," Ethan said.
"It might feel fake at first," Dr. Chen agreed. "But the more you practice, the more your brain will start to believe it. Dreams are just stories your brain tells itself. You can learn to write a different story."
Ethan tried it.
Every night for a week, he sat in bed and imagined the dream with a new ending. He imagined himself opening the door and saying, "Go away, Sarah. You're not welcome here." He imagined himself standing tall, not frozen. He imagined himself protecting Lily without fear.
The dreams didn't stop.
But they changed.
The next time he dreamed about Sarah, he wasn't frozen. He could move. He could speak. He walked to the door, looked through the peephole, and said, "No."
Sarah's face crumbled.
She turned around and walked away.
Ethan woke up feeling lighter than he had in months.
It wasn't a cure. He still thought about Sarah sometimes. He still felt scared sometimes. He still checked the locks before bed and kept his phone close and listened for footsteps in the hall.
But he wasn't trapped anymore.
He was free.
And that, he realized, was the most important thing.
CHAPTER 14: The Family Secret
Ethan's mom had never told him the whole story.
He knew the basics — Sarah was her sister, Sarah had given birth to Lily, Sarah had lost custody, Sarah had spent years trying to get her back. But the details were fuzzy. The gaps were filled with whispers and half-truths and things his mom didn't want to talk about.
One night, after Lily was asleep, Ethan asked her.
"Mom? Can you tell me the rest?"
His mom was sitting on the couch, reading a book. She looked up, her eyebrows raised. "The rest of what?"
"About Sarah. About what happened. About why she lost custody."
His mom closed her book. She set it on the coffee table. She took a deep breath.
"Are you sure you want to know?"
"I'm sure."
His mom patted the couch next to her. Ethan sat down.
"Sarah was always... different," she began. "Even when we were kids. She felt things more intensely than other people. She loved harder. She got angrier faster. She had a hard time controlling her emotions."
"When did it start?"
"Probably when she was a teenager. She started using drugs — first marijuana, then pills, then harder stuff. She dropped out of school. She ran away from home. She got into trouble with the police."
"Did Grandma and Grandpa try to help her?"
"They tried. But Sarah didn't want help. She thought she was fine. She thought everyone else was the problem." His mom paused. "When she got pregnant with Lily, we thought — we hoped — that it would change her. That having a baby would give her something to live for."
"But it didn't."
"No. It made things worse. She was using while she was pregnant — she didn't know, or she didn't care, or both. Lily was born addicted to opioids."
Ethan's stomach turned.
"She spent two weeks in the NICU," his mom continued. "Two weeks of withdrawal. Two weeks of screaming and shaking and not sleeping. It was the worst thing I've ever seen."
"I didn't know that."
"I know. I didn't want you to know. I didn't want you to think of Lily differently."
"I don't."
"I know. But I was scared." His mom wiped her eyes. "After Lily was born, the state took custody. They gave Sarah a chance to get clean, to get her life together, to prove she could be a good mother. And she tried. She really did. She went to rehab. She went to therapy. She got a job. She stayed clean for almost a year."
"What happened?"
"She relapsed. Three days before she was supposed to get Lily back, she relapsed. She overdosed. She almost died."
Ethan couldn't imagine it — Sarah, the woman who had smiled at him through the peephole, lying in a hospital bed, hooked up to machines.
"That's when I decided to adopt Lily," his mom said. "I couldn't let her go into foster care. I couldn't let her be raised by strangers. She was my niece. She was family. She deserved a chance."
"Did Sarah fight it?"
"At first, no. She was too sick to fight. But after she got better — after she got out of the hospital — she changed her mind. She wanted Lily back. She thought she was ready."
"But she wasn't."
"No. She wasn't. And the court agreed." His mom's voice cracked. "But Sarah never accepted it. She never accepted that she'd lost. She blamed me. She blamed the system. She blamed everyone but herself."
"That's why she came to our house."
"Yes. That's why."
Ethan sat with that for a while.
"Do you feel guilty?" he asked.
"Every day."
"Even though you did the right thing?"
"Even though I did the right thing." His mom looked at him. "Guilt isn't rational, Ethan. It doesn't care about right or wrong. It just cares about feelings."
"How do you deal with it?"
"I talk about it. With you. With Dr. Chen. With people who love me." She reached out and took his hand. "And I remind myself that I did the best I could with the information I had. That's all anyone can do."
Ethan squeezed her hand.
"I don't blame you," he said. "For what it's worth."
His mom smiled. It was a watery smile, the kind that came with tears, but it was real.
"That's worth everything," she said.
They sat on the couch for a long time, not talking, just being together.
Outside, the night was quiet.
Inside, for the first time in a long time, there were no secrets.
CHAPTER 15: Two Years Later
Two years after the doorbell rang, the Keller family went to the zoo again.
It was a different zoo — the Cincinnati Zoo, this time, bigger and better than the one in Columbus. Lily had been begging to see Fiona the hippo for months, and their mom had finally given in.
"I can't believe you're almost seven," Ethan said, watching Lily run ahead of them on the path.
"I can't believe you're almost fourteen," Lily shot back. "You're practically old."
"Practically ancient," Ethan agreed.
Their mom laughed. She was wearing a sundress and sandals and a wide-brimmed hat that made her look like she was on vacation. She looked younger than she had in years. Happier.
The zoo was crowded — it was a Saturday in June, the first really warm day of the summer — but they didn't mind. They wandered through the exhibits, stopping to take pictures, eating soft pretzels, drinking lemonade that was more sugar than juice.
They saw Fiona.
Lily pressed her face against the glass and stared at the hippo for a solid ten minutes, her mouth open, her eyes wide.
"She's so big," Lily whispered.
"She's so cute," their mom said.
"She's so hungry," Ethan said, watching Fiona eat a pumpkin. "She ate that whole thing in like two bites."
Lily laughed. "I want a hippo."
"You can't have a hippo."
"Why not?"
"Because hippos are dangerous. They kill more people than sharks."
Lily considered this. "I still want one."
They walked to the gift shop and bought Lily a stuffed hippo, which she immediately named "Fiona Jr." She carried it around for the rest of the day, even though it was almost as big as she was.
At the end of the afternoon, they found a bench in the shade and sat down to rest. Lily was already half-asleep, her head on their mom's shoulder, Fiona Jr. tucked under her arm.
Ethan looked out at the zoo — the families, the children, the animals. Everyone was laughing and talking and living their lives. No one knew what the Keller family had been through. No one could see the scars.
"Ethan?" his mom said.
"Yeah?"
"Are you happy?"
He thought about it. Happy was a big word. Happy was a complicated word.
"I'm okay," he said. "I'm more than okay. I'm... content."
His mom smiled. "Content is good. Content is underrated."
"Can I ask you something?"
"Anything."
"Do you ever think about her? About Sarah?"
His mom was quiet for a moment. "Sometimes. Less than I used to."
"What do you think about?"
"I think about who she could have been. If things had been different. If she'd gotten the help she needed. If she'd made different choices."
"Do you miss her?"
"I miss the sister I had when we were kids. The one who taught me how to ride a bike. The one who let me borrow her clothes. The one who made me laugh so hard I couldn't breathe." His mom's voice was soft. "But that sister has been gone for a long time. Maybe she never really existed. Maybe I imagined her."
Ethan didn't know what to say.
"What about you?" his mom asked. "Do you think about her?"
"Sometimes. I think about the night she came to our house. I think about what could have happened if I hadn't moved the couch. If I hadn't hidden Lily. If I hadn't pulled the cord."
"But you did."
"I did."
"That's not luck, Ethan. That's you. That's who you are."
Ethan looked at his hands. They were bigger now. Stronger. The hands of someone who had done something brave.
"I'm not the same person I was before," he said.
"None of us are."
"Is that bad?"
"I don't think so." His mom shifted Lily on her shoulder. "I think we're better. Stronger. More aware of what matters."
"And what matters?"
"Family. Love. Each other." She looked at him, her eyes bright. "That's all that's ever mattered."
Ethan leaned his head on her shoulder. It was a little awkward now — he was almost as tall as she was — but he made it work.
"I love you, Mom," he said.
"I love you too, Ethan. More than you'll ever know."
Lily stirred in her sleep. "I love pizza," she mumbled.
Ethan laughed. His mom laughed. Lily opened her eyes, confused, then closed them again.
They sat on the bench until the sun started to set, until the zoo started to empty, until the only sounds were the birds and the crickets and the distant roar of a lion.
Then they stood up, gathered their things, and walked to the car.
Lily held Ethan's hand on the way to the parking lot. Her hand was small and warm and sticky from the lemonade.
"Ethan?" she said.
"Yeah?"
"I'm glad you're my brother."
Ethan's heart swelled.
"I'm glad you're my sister," he said.
They got in the car and drove home.
The sun was setting behind them, painting the sky in shades of orange and pink. The windows were down. The radio was playing a song Ethan didn't know.
He looked at his mom. She was singing along, off-key, happy.
He looked at Lily. She was holding Fiona Jr. and Mr. Hops, one in each arm, her eyes closed, her lips curved in a small smile.
He looked at himself in the rearview mirror.
He looked tired. He looked older. He looked like someone who had been through something and survived.
But he also looked like someone who was going to be okay.
And that, he realized, was enough.
That was more than enough.
The end.
EPILOGUE
Six months later.
Ethan started high school in the fall.
It was scary at first — new building, new teachers, new faces — but he found his footing. He joined the robotics club. He made the soccer team. He got a B+ in algebra, which was better than he'd expected.
Lily started second grade. She lost her two front teeth and looked like a jack-o'-lantern for three months. She still slept with Mr. Hops, but she also slept with Fiona Jr. now, which meant her bed was getting crowded.
Their mom got a promotion at work. She was the head nurse now, which meant more money and more responsibility and more stress. But she smiled more. Laughed more. Relaxed more.
They didn't talk about Sarah.
Not because they were hiding from it — but because they didn't need to. The story had been told. The wounds had been healed. The scars would always be there, but scars were just proof that you had survived.
On the third anniversary of the incident, they ordered pizza and watched a movie and ate ice cream straight from the carton.
No hot chocolate.
No toasts.
No speeches.
Just pizza and a movie and ice cream.
Just a family, together, being normal.
And that, Ethan thought, was the best kind of anniversary.
THE END
Post a Comment for "Pinky Promise: The Babysitter's Last Night Part 2"